What Is Your Organization’s Competition Culture?

The trick is fostering the kind of healthy employee competition that enhances the organization as a whole and not just one person’s self-interest.

At some organizations, employees compete against each other for the common good. For example, I have heard that advertising agencies sometimes have two employees compete against each other to see who can come up with the best pitch for a client. Salespeople compete to see who can sell the most for the company they both work for. Those two examples illustrate healthy competition that benefits the organization.

But sometimes competition is focused on personal ambition and insecurity much more than it is about helping the company do better. In some cases, this negative form of competition can even undercut the good of an organization, leading to one employee pushing another equally, or even more, valuable employee out.

Create Structured Competition

A sense of competition is part of being human, and even animals other than humans appear to gravitate toward competition. The need to dominate is indomitable, you might say. Anyone with two cats can see this playing out as the alpha cat often pushes the beta cat to the periphery, especially during mealtimes.

An organization with a healthy culture acknowledges that employees will try to dominate each other by competing and creates structured competition. In sales, this is easy to measure, but in other kinds of work, such as the publishing world I operate in, it’s harder. A publishing company could use readership metrics, but there are so many factors that impact those measurements that it often isn’t a level playing field. One publication may cater to a rapidly growing audience while another is focused on serving a rapidly shrinking audience.

For non-sales employees, like those of us working in publishing, the competition could be the person who develops the greatest number of new (and reliable) sources of information over the course of a year, or the person who comes up with the most new ideas (at my first full-time job, I won what the company called its “Entrepreneur’s Award”).

The competition should be out in the open and labeled as such, and it should be a fair fight so you’re truly comparing apples to apples. No comparing two employees who have uneven challenges in the level of support they each receive from junior employees and the viability of the respective market niches they are serving.

Task the Winners with Teaching Colleagues

If one employee is the star salesperson, be sure they get recognition and are celebrated (in addition to getting their monetary reward), but also tap them to train their less successful colleagues. Make it known from the start of the structured competition that winners will serve as guides for their colleagues and that if they do this well, it will count toward greater opportunities for upward growth.

They could give a presentation on their sales approach to the group and then have their colleagues individually shadow them for a few hours, listening or sitting in on their sales calls and seeing how they put together their presentations. They could even witness the sales presentation itself, seeing how their successful colleague answers difficult questions from prospective customers.

Beware of the Signs of Unhealthy Competition

While you stoke healthy competition, you need to simultaneously be on the lookout for the unhealthy kind.

A common manifestation of this is the go-getter employee who criticizes how another employee is doing their work but doesn’t offer to help, instead making bids to take over.

“Brenda, you’ve done a great job with your sales presentations, and I love how organized you are. Rather than seeking to take over Susan’s territory and become her manager, I’d like to see you mentor her,” this competitive employee’s boss could say.

“That’s what I’m saying—I want to lead Susan to show her the way. I want to supervise her work to make sure it’s done well and we all benefit.”

“Let’s focus instead on you lending a hand to your colleague to help her do better, rather than having your ‘help’ tied to dominating her.” That’s what I would like to hear a savvy manager say to an employee like this who uses competition to dominate colleagues rather than to benefit the organization.

How do you foster the kind of competition that enhances the whole organization, and not just one person’s self-interest?