Navigating the Talent Gap in the Insurance Industry

Explore the key workforce challenges currently confronting the insurance industry and strategies to ensure a sustainable future.

The insurance industry is seeing rapid transformation through the implementation of new technologies and enhanced processes, and 90 percent of companies in the space believe digital transformation is a key component of strategic plans. Despite this, the sector finds itself facing critical workforce challenges that directly impact its ability to keep pace with this accelerating evolution.

Current challenges – including an aging workforce, millennial disinterest, and underskilled workers – have resulted in a significant talent gap, hindering the industry’s ability to meet the needs of policyholders in an increasingly digital and complex world. This article will explore the key workforce challenges currently confronting the industry and strategies to ensure a sustainable future amidst these transformative times.

Key Workforce Challenges Facing the Industry

The insurance industry’s workforce landscape has undergone significant changes in recent years. The COVID-19 pandemic accelerated the adoption of remote and hybrid work models, which have become a lasting trend. Digitization and automation transform the way insurance companies operate and interact with customers. Moreover, customer expectations have evolved, demanding more personalized and seamless experiences.

While the industry continues to evolve, there are a number of challenges contributing to the insurance talent gap:

Generational Turnover: One of the most pressing challenges the insurance industry faces is generational turnover. A substantial portion of the current insurance workforce is aging rapidly, with professionals aged 55 and older increasing by 74 percent in the last decade. It is estimated that over the next 15 years, 50 percent of the current workforce will retire, leaving more than 400,000 open positions unfilled. This issue is compounded by the fact that millennials have shown little interest in pursuing careers with companies in the industry, with less than 25 percent of the insurance workforce being under the age of 35.

Underskilled Workforce: As the insurance industry evolves, driven by technological advancements and shifting customer expectations, a significant skills gap has emerged within the workforce. Traditional business methods are becoming obsolete, and employees must adapt to new processes and systems. The failure to close these skill gaps can impede the industry’s ability to meet the demands of a rapidly changing marketplace. Furthermore, a lack of clear communication and execution of company vision and culture exacerbates this challenge.

Industry Perception: Many perceive the insurance industry as a dull, bureaucratic, and old-fashioned sector. To emphasize this point, 44 percent of millennials do not find an insurance career interesting. The industry must actively work to change this misperception to attract new talent. Initiatives promoting the industry as forward-thinking, socially responsible, consumer-centric, and digitally driven can go a long way in attracting fresh, diverse talent.

Leadership Development: The insurance industry lacks comprehensive mentorship and training programs for leadership development across all skill levels. The absence of a clear path for employees to grow into leadership roles can lead to dissatisfaction and attrition.

Long-Term Solutions and Best Practices

When confronting the insurance talent gap, it is increasingly evident that short-term fixes will not suffice. To secure a thriving future, the insurance sector must implement long-term solutions and best practices that bridge the present workforce challenges and fortify the industry for the challenges yet to come.

To address the talent gap and ensure a sustainable workforce, the insurance industry must consider the following long-term solutions and best practices:

Prioritize Culture: Fostering a strong organizational culture is paramount. Current and new employees need a clear understanding of the company’s vision and culture, as well as the “why” behind it all. Once they understand this, they can become invested in how and why their role can be impactful to the overall company mission.  In addition, this sense of purpose can drive engagement and retention.

Positively Promote the Industry: Creating avenues to promote the industry as forward-thinking, socially responsible, consumer-centric and digitally driven is critical to attracting new and young talent. This could involve partnerships with educational institutions, industry events and marketing campaigns that highlight the industry’s positive aspects.

Provide Opportunities for Growth: Offering a clear career path, or at least opportunities for growth and development within the organization, is essential. When employees see a future with their current employer, they are more likely to stay.

Offer Mentorship and Leadership Programs: Implementing mentorship and leadership development programs at all levels of the organization can help identify and nurture future leaders, reducing turnover and ensuring continuity.

Recruitment Strategies for Young Talent

To attract younger generations to the insurance industry, companies must revamp their recruitment strategies. This involves challenging preconceived notions about the industry and emphasizing its positive attributes, such as:

  • Highlighting the industry’s role in protecting individuals, families, and businesses from financial risks, and emphasizing the positive impact insurance professionals can have on their communities.
  • Showcasing the industry’s commitment to embracing technology and innovation, making it an exciting space for tech-savvy individuals.
  • Promoting the opportunities for career growth and development within the industry, as millennials and Gen Z employees value continuous learning and advancement.
  • Emphasizing a balanced work environment that accommodates personal and professional life, especially in a world where remote work is increasingly prevalent.

The insurance industry is an excellent career platform for young professionals, particularly given the technological evolution and changing policyholder demands. Companies within this sector actively seek individuals who can contribute to customer relations, data analytics, technology, AI/machine learning, creative problem-solving, adaptability, agility, and leadership.

Despite facing substantial workforce challenges due to generational shifts, skill discrepancies, and perception issues, the insurance industry can overcome these hurdles by focusing on long-term solutions and strategic recruitment. By emphasizing innovation, social responsibility, and career development, the insurance sector can attract and retain the high-caliber talent it requires to flourish in today’s dynamic world.

Troy Stewart
Over the past 12 years, Troy Stewart has risen through the ranks at Brush Claims to now serve as its President and Chief Operating Officer. Stewart is an innovative leader in the insurance claims space and is actively driving the evolution of the insurance industry forward. Stewart started at Brush Claims as a field adjuster, which gives him unique insight now as a leader. He then shifted into a quality assurance review position, where he rose to the ranks of Vice President of Daily Claims. In his role as VP of Daily Claims, he was tasked with developing Brush Claims’ Quality Control program and ongoing field training guides. Throughout his six years in this role, he also spearheaded growing the Daily Claims department and oversaw the management, supervision and execution of quality claims reporting in the 48 contiguous states. Appointed as COO, President and partner in 2018, Stewart was essential in the development of Brush Claims’ software suite Hubvia, which plans to launch its beta version in 2024, and also played a large role in the evolution of their HyDAP claims handling program, which boasts a 68-hour cycle time. In this role, he is able to push his vision of tech-driven, human-led claims. In 2021, Stewart participated on behalf of Brush Claims in cohort seven of the prestigious Lloyd’s Lab by Lloyd’s of London, the esteemed insurance market leader.